Christmas Joys

  • Heather Vogel Frederick

“Accept my thanks for your beautiful holiday gifts, and my warm wishes for your happiness and prosperity,” wrote Mary Baker Eddy in The Christian Science Journal of January 1888 under the heading “Christmas Joys.” During the 1887 holiday season, she had received some 50 gifts from her students and followers, gifts which, she said, “gladdened my Christmas.”1

Among them was a handsome mantel clock sent to her by Hannah Larminie, a Christian Science practitioner from Hyde Park, Illinois. Hannah had received instruction from Mrs. Eddy at the Massachusetts Metaphysical College three times in as many years.2

“May all joy and peace be yours, this Christmas time!” Hannah wrote in a letter to her teacher that accompanied the gift. “The real Christmas is nearer to us today than ever before, and we can rejoice with you now, in a fuller understanding, trusting that ere long we may come into the full joy of the new birth in Christ. God is surely with us, and we have every reason to be glad.”3

Hannah told Mrs. Eddy, who called the timepiece “interesting,”4 that it was modeled after a clock tower in Lausanne, Switzerland, she and her husband had visited, and that it was unusual in that it gave the “time, times, and half a time,” as she put it, quoting the book of Revelation. “I trust it will be a witness of the destruction of all times,” Hannah added, “so that we may enter into the joy of eternity.”5


Hannah Larminie’s Christmas gift to Mrs. Eddy would grace the library at Pleasant View, Mrs. Eddy’s home in Concord, New Hampshire, and later the second-floor hallway of 400 Beacon Street, her final home in Chestnut Hill, Massachusetts. The clock was among the numerous items given to Longyear recently by The Mother Church, The First Church of Christ, Scientist, in Boston, Massachusetts, as part of several gifts of artwork and decorative and household items from 400 Beacon Street.

Another gift that Mrs. Eddy publicly acknowledged in that issue of the Journal was an “exquisite engraving, The Repose in Egypt, elegantly framed.”6 Given to her by Mary Bradford, a Christian Science teacher from Boston, it depicts Mary and Joseph’s flight into Egypt after the birth of Jesus. The artwork would hang in the library at Pleasant View and later in the first-floor hall at Chestnut Hill, and it was also among the items given to Longyear by The Mother Church.

“Le Repose en Egypte,” by Luc-Olivier Merson. Engraving, 2017.007.0004, Longyear Museum collection.

For several years, Mrs. Eddy used the pages of the Christian Science periodicals to publicly thank her gift givers for their thoughtfulness. By 1889, however, she would strike a different note, gently nudging her students and followers in a different direction.

“This year, my beloved Christian Scientists, you must grant me my request, namely, that I be permitted total exemption from Christmas gifts. Also I beg to send to you all a deep-drawn, heart-felt breath of thanks for those things of beauty and use forming themselves in your thoughts to send to Mother. Thus may I close the door of mind on this subject, and open the volume of Life on the pure pages of impersonal presents, pleasures, achievements, and aid.” 7

“Le Repose en Egypte” was located in the library at Pleasant View. The engraving can be seen on the wall at right above the piano. The clock, a gift from Hannah Larminie, is located on the mantel at left. Illustration, “Pleasant View Home Surroundings of Rev. Mary Baker Eddy,” 1896, by J. F. Gilman and H. E. Carlton, Longyear Museum collection.

While the lengthy lists of gift acknowledgements in the periodicals waned, despite Mrs. Eddy’s direction her students’ enthusiasm for sending Christmas gifts did not – at least not right away. Bradford Sherman, for instance, a practitioner and teacher from Chicago whose hobby was painting, sent her an oil painting shortly after her new directive was issued.

Back in the summer of 1884, he’d given her a painting titled “Isle of Wight,” which had sparked a poem in response.8


“Isle of Wight” by Bradford Sherman, 1884. Oil painting, 2017.007.0024, Longyear Museum collection.

And in 1887, the same Christmas that Hannah Larminie and Mary Bradford sent their gifts, he gave Mrs. Eddy another – a seascape that she praised as “grand.” The artist himself described it as “an ideal picture of the ship Christian Science nearing the port, leaving the rocks, shadows, and shoals of mortal belief behind.”9

“Isle of Wight,” by Bradford Sherman, was placed above a mantel in a parlor at Pleasant View. Illustration, “Pleasant View Home Surroundings of Rev. Mary Baker Eddy,” 1896, by J. F. Gilman and H. E. Carlton, Longyear Museum collection.

Like “Isle of Wight,” the seascape also inspired a poem of gratitude from Mrs. Eddy, this one published in The Christian Science Journal of January 1888.10

Perhaps in hopes of coaxing a third poem from her, Mr. Sherman sent along “Winter Landscape” the following year, in 1889. A depiction of John Greenleaf Whittier’s New England birthplace, it touched a chord in his teacher. Years earlier, while living in Amesbury, Massachusetts, shortly after her discovery of Christian Science, she had healed the renowned poet of an illness. And she was also a lifelong fan of Whittier’s poetry, including his well-known narrative poem, Snow-Bound: A Winter Idyl, published in 1866, the same year that she experienced her landmark healing.

“Winter Landscape,” by Bradford Sherman, depicts Whittier’s birthplace in Haverhill, Massachusetts. Oil painting, 2017.007.0051, Longyear Museum collection.

“I look at Whittier’s Birthplace,” she wrote in The Christian Science Journal of February 1890, “an oil painting by Bradford Sherman, beautifully framed—and wonder if ever poet and painter met more warmly with pen and brush in so frigid a scene as this illustration of the inimitable poem ‘Snow Bound.’”11

Mrs. Eddy placed the oil painting in the guest room at Pleasant View, where all her visitors could admire it. With the move to Chestnut Hill, it found a new home in Calvin Frye’s office. Today, along with “Isle of Wight,” Mr. Sherman’s “Winter Landscape” is part of Longyear’s collection. (The whereabouts of the seascape is unknown at this point in time.)

“Winter Landscape,” by Bradford Sherman, was located in a guest room at Pleasant View. The painting is on the wall above the mantel. Illustration, “Pleasant View Home Surroundings of Rev. Mary Baker Eddy,” 1896, by J. F. Gilman and H. E. Carlton, Longyear Museum collection.

As the years progressed, Mrs. Eddy moved away from public thanks for holiday gifts that she received. But her appreciation didn’t stop, and she continued to pour her gratitude onto the page through her pen.

“My thanks though late are fresh and the birds’ bells of China lie in my library,” she wrote to two of her students in January 1903.12

Part of the set of bells to which Mrs. Eddy was likely referring in her thank you letter. Decorative objects, 2018.033.0186, Longyear Museum collection.

Sarah Pike Conger, wife of United States Minister to China Edwin Conger, along with her friend Maurine Campbell, had sent a Christmas gift of a set of seven dome-shaped bells and a striker. Today, these, too, are part of Longyear’s collection, thanks to the generosity of The Mother Church.

Described as Chinese dinner bells, these graduated dome-shaped bells are made of bronze with a painted floral and bird design. Decorative objects, 2018.033.0186, Longyear Museum collection.

More than the gifts themselves, however, what Mrs. Eddy truly prized was the love behind them.

“The value . . . consists largely in the thoughts which these beautiful things express,” she wrote. “The tender heartthrobs of vital cooperation that they bring give me strength and faith in the future; they assure me that the few faithful adherents to Christian Science will be found equal to sustain our cause; and the love wherewith they have loved me was kindled from the divine Source, that replenishes it, and will extend its healing power over all the earth.”13



  1. Mary Baker Eddy, “Christmas Joys,” The Christian Science Journal 5 (January 1888): 534. Ever the teacher, she also included this line: “The Star that led the Wisemen of old is leading the wise of our time. It is the central ray in the firmament of Soul.”
  2. Hannah Larminie was in the Primary class of 1885, the Normal class of 1886, and the Obstetrical class of 1887. She would also enter an additional Primary class (not unusual at the time) in March of 1888.
  3. “Christmas Joys,” 533.
  4. Ibid.
  5. “And to the woman were given two wings of a great eagle, that she might fly into the wilderness, into her place, where she is nourished for a time, and times, and half a time, from the face of the serpent.” Revelation 12:14. “Christmas Joys,” 533.
  6. Ibid, 534.
  7. Mary Baker Eddy, “Early Chimes,” The Christian Science Weekly 1 (November 10, 1898): 4; The Christian Science Journal 16 (December 1898): 591. The Christian Science Weekly was a precursor to the Christian Science Sentinel. “Early Chimes” was later reprinted in Mary Baker Eddy’s The First Church of Christ, Scientist, and Miscellany, 256. “Mother” was a term of affection for Mrs. Eddy often used by early Christian Scientists.
  8. Mary Baker G. Eddy, “Isle of Wight,” Journal of Christian Science 2 (August 2, 1884): 1. (The Journal of Christian Science was a precursor to The Christian Science Journal.) This poem was later reprinted in Mary Baker Eddy’s Miscellaneous Writings 1883-1896, 392-393.
  9. “Christmas Joys,” 533.
  10. M.B. G. Eddy, “To Bradford Sherman, C.S. D.,” The Christian Science Journal 5 (January 1888): 534.
  11. Mary B. G. Eddy, “Christmas Offerings,” The Christian Science Journal 7 (February 1890): 547.
  12. Mary Baker Eddy to Sarah Pike Conger, January 28, 1903, L06151, The Mary Baker Eddy Collection, The Mary Baker Eddy Library, Boston, Massachusetts.
  13. Mary Baker G. Eddy, “Christmas Favors,” The Christian Science Journal 4 (January 1887): 247.