Evidence Converging: Comparing Two photographs

By
  • Cheryl P. Moneyhun
-
Photograph of Mrs. Eddy’s grandsons at the time of their visit to her at Chestnut Hill, Massachusetts, on July 16, 1910. Longyear Museum collection.
Photograph of Mary Baker Eddy’s grandsons George Washington Glover, III, and Andrew Jackson Glover. Recently acquired for the Longyear Museum collection.

Longyear has recently acquired a print of an historical photograph of Mary Baker Eddy’s grandsons, George Washington Glover, III, and Andrew Jackson Glover. This “new” image is strikingly similar to another photograph which is already in the Longyear collection. Yet, there are two important differences: the background, and the packages in their hands.

The photo Longyear had previously acquired was taken by a newspaperman outside Mrs. Eddy’s home in Chestnut Hill, Massachusetts, on July 16, 1910. But where was the new one taken? Who took it? When?

Photographs of the Chestnut Hill estate at that time do not show a rustic fence like the one behind George and Andrew in the new photo, so it seems unlikely that it was taken there. Also, they are not holding the packages. Then, where?

Inscription by Mrs. Eddy in the copy of her book Science and Health with Key to the Scriptures which she gave to grandson George on July 16, 1910. Longyear Museum collection.

A little background to the story of George and Andrew Glover’s visit may give a hint.

Mrs. Eddy’s grandsons took a train in July 1910 from their home in Lead, South Dakota, bound for New England. They went first to Waterloo, New Hampshire, where they were to be guests of ex-Senator William E. Chandler.*

From there the two young men went to see their grandmother on July 16, her birthday. There they presented her with a pin made of gold from the Glover gold mine — a gift from their father which Mrs. Eddy cherished and displayed on her “whatnot.”

She gave each of her grandsons a signed copy of Science and Health with Key to the Scriptures, the packages seen in their hands in the photograph.

And so, what does the evidence tell us about the recently acquired photograph?

The apparent age of the grandsons and the similarity of attire to the photograph from the Longyear collection strongly suggest that the new one was taken at about the same time as the other:  the summer of 1910. But the crude, low fence behind them indicates that this picture was not taken at Mrs. Eddy’s home, but at a more rustic location — likely Chandler’s farm in Waterloo, New Hampshire.

Notes


*William E. Chandler was the chief attorney representing their father in the highly publicized “Next Friends” lawsuit. The suit, brought in March 1907, contended that Mary Baker Eddy, then 85 years of age, was incompetent to manage her property and needed protection. While ostensibly brought to protect her, the goal of the suit was to discredit her and Christian Science and to gain control over her sizable fortune. The suit was withdrawn in August 1907, after her competency was indisputably established by the court. The fact that the suit was withdrawn with no verdict meant that Chandler remained a potential adversary.

This article originally appeared in the 2012 fall/winter Report to Members.

Support Longyear’s research

Your donation helps support our ongoing research into Mary Baker Eddy’s history